Buttermilk's Chicken Reviews, Ratings & Menu

General Info

Nestled in the heart of East Islip, NY, Buttermilk's Chicken offers an unforgettable dining experience for chicken lovers. Located at 93 E Main St, this charming chicken restaurant brings comfort food to the next level with a variety of mouthwatering dishes that will have you coming back for more. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or a casual lunch, Buttermilk's Chicken has something to satisfy every craving.

One of the standout dishes at Buttermilk's Chicken is their Buff-A-Leu Chicken Sandwich. This flavor-packed sandwich features a crispy, golden-fried chicken breast slathered in a tangy buffalo sauce, topped with fresh lettuce and a cool drizzle of ranch. It's the perfect balance of heat and coolness, making it a fan favorite. If you're in the mood for something a bit lighter but just as satisfying, the Fried Chicken Salad is a great choice. Crisp greens are paired with crunchy fried chicken tenders, then tossed with delicious toppings that will leave you savoring every bite.

Buttermilk's Chicken is also famous for its crispy and flavorful Chicken Wings. Perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection, these wings make a great appetizer or snack. Whether you prefer them mild or spicy, they are sure to please your taste buds.

When it comes to service, Buttermilk's Chicken truly shines. Their fast service ensures you won't have to wait long for your meal, even during busy lunch hours. Plus, the restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with convenient parking available right outside. If you're on the go, the restaurant offers a great option for a quick bite that doesn’t sacrifice quality for speed. Free street parking is also available, making it easy to pop in whenever you're in the area.

Buttermilk's Chicken is the perfect spot to enjoy a hearty, flavorful meal in a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a sandwich, salad, or wings, the menu is packed with options that cater to all tastes. With fast service and a convenient location, it’s no wonder this chicken restaurant has become a local favorite in East Islip. Don’t miss out on the chance to try some of the best chicken in town!

What customers say?

“ Great chicken sandwich, Amazing Corn Bread, onion rings are delish and fries are crispy. Really good “faster” food. ”

- Cins Phins -

“ It was good hot chicken , fresh out of the fryer chicken. The service here was awesome. The girl at the counter was friendly and kind. The atmosphere was nice and quiet. A very super clean place. I love it anyone should come and definitely try their jalapeño poppers they are great. They are filled with cheese inside. I give this place a ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ if they had cheese fries but atleast the poppers made up for it.. service 5 ⭐ for sure.. ”

- Wanda iris Martinez (Wandi M) -

“ My husband and I love this place! Any time we’re in town visiting we make sure to stop here for lunch. The chicken is the juiciest chicken and even the sides are fantastic! Staff is incredibly friendly and kind and attentive. Seating is cozy and comfortable. 10/10 recommend! ”

- Emily Durand -

“ Food is SO good that it should get a 6th star. At the first bite you can taste it is 100% buttermilk chicken. Everything is made to order so it doesn't get better than that. Staff was amazing, kind, patient and helpful. Fries have the right amount of salt and the onion rings are battered perfectly. Don't walk run here and enjoy a hot and delicious meal!! ”

- Jose Torres -

“ The chicken is impossibly delectable. Seems like it's double fried and dry rubbed. I got the two piece spicy dark meat combo to stay and I'm glad I did. I soon after got a 4 piece spicy box and boy the flavor carried through. Whenever I'm back in the area I will definitely return. Soft, moist cornbread and delicious Mac and cheese. ”

- Paul Persaud -

“ Really happy to discover this little gem! Fresh made sandwiches with homemade sauces that absolutely hit the spot. The service was friendly and the food came out quickly despite being made to order. The atmosphere was cuter and more comfortable than your average chicken shop too. We both only got the Crispy classic sandwich but were very pleasantly surprised and will be back to try more menu items, especially the tendies. ”

- Will Neal -

“ Great chicken sandwiches. Beat the chains like chick fil a hands down. The buttermilk breading on the chicken is super crispy and keeps the chicken moist. ”

- Peter Zsamboky -

“ If you want incredible tasting chicken and more, come to this place. This is a short and simple review because it is all good. ”

- Toby Music -

Welcome to Buttermilk's Chicken

General Info

Buttermilk's Chicken menu

Buttermilk's Chicken Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places